Thoughts/question about Colorado State game
(Written by kencraw)
A question, that I haven’t seen answered anywhere to my satisfaction was why wasn’t Forsett carrying the ball in the 4th quarter? It doesn’t seem he was injured that anyone can tell, and there is a rumor that he was given a tongue lashing on the sideline for some missed blocking assignments in the 3rd quarter, but nothing definitive has come out. The other theory seems to be that they were resting him but that doesn’t make sense after he didn’t come back in on the final grind out the clock drive unless perhaps he had already de-taped or something. In any case, inquiring minds want to know so if anyone has any solid info, I’d love to hear it.
An observation that I had during the radio broadcast was Starkey commenting on the officiating. While there have been numerous times he’s make reference to a particular call and whether someone looked in bounds or anything, I have NEVER heard him EVER make a SINGLE comment about the fairness of the officiating. I haven’t seen the TV broadcast yet but I know when I heard him making those comments on the radio that either Starkey is losing his objectivity, which he has done a tremendous job of not doing over the years like so many announcers have (one of the reasons I like him), or the officiating must be REALLY REALLY bad. It’ll be interesting to see the TV coverage. It also seemed like the officiating took a sharp turn in the Bears favor midway through the 4th quarter just based on the number of calls. It could be the Colorado State guys were getting desperate and they were fouling more, or it could have been that Tedford’s on-the-field complaints (who also never bashes the refs but went so far as to call them ridiculous at his halftime interview) got to them and they were making amends (which I can tell you as a former ref, happens all the time).
A shout-out to Jordon Kay for coming in as the field goal kicker and doing an amazing job. One of the things Cal seems to have a knack for is getting good special teams specialists. Long snappers, punters, kickers… Cal always seems to have top-notch talent for this. I think that’s a sign of good recruiting.
Three cheers to our Pac-10 bretheren for holding up the image of the Pac-10. Oregon drove a stake through the heart of Michigan today and Washington solidly beat one of the best non-BCS teams in the country in Boise St. Add in UCLA’s handling of BYU and the Pac-10 continues to impress. Don’t think that the national pollsters aren’t taking notice because they are. The only downside is that the Oregon victory over Michigan will be looked through the very pessimistic lens of their loss to App. State. At this point Pac-10 fans need to be big fans of Tennessee and Michigan in their respective conferences because it will help make those important non-conference victories look all that more impressive.
UPDATE 9/8/07, 7:00 AM: The Chronicle has the best data-point so far on why Forsett wasn’t in the game at the end: “Instead, Cal got the ball back and relied on its brawn to clinch the win. Montgomery, who was playing in the clutch role because starter Justin Forsett got a back stinger in the third quarter, ran five times for 25 yards on the drive, eating up the final 2:47.” So it looks like it was an injury, albeit a minor one. To steal yet again from Starkey and his comment after the Jahvid Best TD: “It’s too bad they don’t have any depth at tailback.” When you’ve got backs like Montgomery and Best to backup Forsett, I think it’s pretty reasonable to keep Forsett out of the game with a back stinger.
September 8th, 2007 at 10:22 pm
Bad officiating, Ken. The worst example: they used replay to correct a bad spot (it was in Cal’s favor, but it was a TERRIBLE spot) — and yet not a half an hour later they don’t use replay to check on a CSU touchdown that appeared to not be within two yards of the end zone plane.
Perhaps it was really a touchdown. But why wouldn’t you review that play? You’ll review a first-down spot, but not a touchdown?
September 9th, 2007 at 1:55 pm
I hate bad officiating as much as the next guy, but we can’t let it be an excuse to defeat (unless it’s the NBA, where officials can make or break a game).
September 9th, 2007 at 1:56 pm
Err, bad play. I’m not sure why I said defeat.
September 9th, 2007 at 5:14 pm
There is no way, at all, totally, and without a doubt in my mind that the CSU goal line touch down call was absolute and total (earmuffs) BS. They showed it several times on TV and Haine (or however his underpants name is spelled) made it past the plane.
No.
September 9th, 2007 at 5:16 pm
Oops, started with a negative declaration, then ended with a positive. Me no write english good.
You get the point. Bad, bad, bad call that should’ve been reviewed.
September 9th, 2007 at 7:50 pm
Pretty sure you’ve already heard, but just in case you haven’t…but I read that Forsett suffered a stinger and that’s why he was held out in the 4th.
September 9th, 2007 at 7:51 pm
Pretty sure you’ve already heard, but just in case you haven’t…I read that Forsett suffered a stinger and that’s why he was held out in the 4th.
September 9th, 2007 at 9:21 pm
oops! ignore my last comment…didn’t see that you added an update.
September 10th, 2007 at 5:32 am
What about the obvious no call on pass interference in the end zone?
The replay officals really blew it. I agree that both the QB sneak was not a TD, his knee was down and the respot after calling it a first down was inconclusive. It seems like the replay officals turned a blind eye on anything that was close in Cal’s favor. I think most officiating is fair, but when you go out of your way to reverse a call that isn’t justified or not look at one that is, well something just doesn’t smell right.