Grading the media coverage
(Written by kencraw)
I’m not going to worry about the 5 PM and 6 PM news coverage (which was horrible in the rush) but what is available this morning:
KTVU: C- (Did alright minus grossly exagerating the EIR short-comings in one spot the middle)
KPIX: B (No glaring errors but refused to state any facts, just what both sides were saying)
KGO-TV: B- (No glaring errors but not equal time for both sides, although the previous night’s video is far better. I’d give that video a B+.)
NBC11: F (video is from before the ruling)
KRON: D (No later update after 6:30 PM (at least on the web) and that one was entirely one-sided)
KCBS: C+ (Starts with the tree-sitter side and only “rebuts” it with University side)
KGO: A- (Very balanced. Starts with the facts and then puts protestors as sidebar)
SFGate: B+ (Reasonable balanced with enough details to make it clear what is going to happen)
CC Times: A+ (On headline alone “Judge rules in UC Berkeley’s favor” but it also has the real details)
Daily Cal: B+ (Generally strong but over quotes the PHA rep. and her bogus arguments)
Oakland Tribune: A+ (same article as CC Times)
For what it’s worth, a couple of reports indicated that they’ve managed to force the tree-sitters into one redwood tree, which is really good news. The bad news is that Dumpster Muffin has a death wish. I work with wood a lot and the problem is that it breaks down relatively quickly. If she keeps shaking that platform, it’s only a matter of time before it structurally collapses. I pray to God (quite literally) that she comes to her senses and stops this suicidal activity.
June 19th, 2008 at 2:51 pm
I’d have a death wish, too, if my parents named me Dumpster! What were Mr. and Mrs. Muffin thinking?
June 19th, 2008 at 3:46 pm
Someone on Bear Insider pointed out the similarity between this protest and the original People’s Park protests when one of the protesters was killed by a police officer.
I think she’d love nothing more than to be a martyr. Dying over landscaping.
June 19th, 2008 at 5:09 pm
[…] did walk by the stadium yesterday after the ruling. Some woman has been yelping at everyone (Dumpster Muffin is her name–God her mommy must have hated her), another crazy was rambling on about “blasting our […]
June 20th, 2008 at 1:39 pm
Ken Crawford – Media Watchdog!
Seriously, nice job, although I don’t know how you managed to watch all those inane local news broadcasts without wanting to stick something sharp in your eye..
June 23rd, 2008 at 9:18 am
Rag, it’s not that hard when you’re already down to one eye from previous eye-sticking episodes. đŸ™‚